June 20, 2007

don’t forget probability

In this video by Oxford mathematician Peter Donnelly, he poses the following hypothetical question:

Given an AIDS test which is 99% accurate, what is the probability you have AIDS if you tested positive.

The interesting part is this isn’t as easy as it sounds, and the rarity of the disease determines the answer as much as anything else. Let’s say for the sake of discussion that on average out of 1 million people, 100 have AIDS. We would then see the following:

  1. Of the 100 people who actually have AIDS, 99 people would correctly test positive. One person would have AIDS and the test wouldn’t catch it.
  2. Of the remaining 999,900 people who do not have AIDS, 9,999  would incorrectly test positive.

This means that of the 1 million people who get tested for AIDS, 10,098 of them would test positive, while only 99 actually have AIDS.

You can take a test which is 99% accurate, have it turn out positive, and still only have a 99/10,098 = 0.98% chance that you actually have AIDS.  An extremely accurate test says you have AIDS, and yet it’s extremely unlikely that you do.

This leads me to agree with former Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli, who famously stated, “There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.”

No Comments »

  1. that was way more interesting than it should have been.

    Comment by Daniel — June 28, 2007 @ 5:36 pm

  2. where are you, dude?

    Comment by rachel — July 31, 2007 @ 11:06 am

  3. This site is woefully outdated. I’ve got a fever and the only cure is more Red.

    Comment by joel — August 3, 2007 @ 11:13 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress